A few years ago, Laura Mickes was teaching her regular undergraduate class on childhood psychological disorders at the University of California, San Diego. It was a weighty subject, so occasionally she would inject a sarcastic comment about her own upbringing to lighten the mood. When she collected her professor evaluations at the end of the year, she was startled by one comment in particular:.
A recent graphic made by Ben Schmidt, an assistant professor of history at Northeastern University, analyzed the words used to describe male and female professors across 14 million reviews on RateMyProfessor.
In every single discipline, male professors were far more likely than female ones to be described as funny. I have a great time with my female friends. I come from the kind of family that deals with minor adversity by making relentless fun of the petty tyrants responsible. Major adversity, we smother in smoked meats. But I maybe make a man laugh once every other month.
Welcome to rich women looking for men
On one hand, we live in the golden age of female comedy. But they might be some of the first to do it with fearless jokes about their vaginas.
Women, suffice it to say, are funny. On the other hand, happy hours during which one man holds forth to a gaggle of raptly amused female onlookers exist. My deftly hilarious female friends exist, and many are eternally single. If men and women are clearly capable of being equally funny, why does humor by non-famous women so often go unappreciated?
InMickes decided to see whether her student had a point. A common way scientists measure funniness is by making undergr—the typical guinea pigs for social-science research—play a version of The New Yorker cartoon-caption contest. For her study, Mickes asked 32 students to write captions for 20 New Yorker cartoons. After the students finished writing their quips, a new set of participants rated the captions.
The difference was small, but still, Mickes was horrified by the. Past research on gender and New Yorker cartoons had been mixed. In a study in the journal Intelligencemale participants also penned more amusing captions than women did. Without prompting, the men wrote funny paragraphs. However, a surprising thing happened when Mickes explicitly told the participants to try to be funny in their paragraphs: Both genders used humor, and in equal measure.
The Intelligence study similarly found that men wrote more captions overall, both funny and lame. In other words, men make more attempts at humor, so they are successful more of the time. If you fail and you're not funny, you lost maybe a few minutes. But if the person laughs, the benefit can be huge. Male participants said that, on a scale from one to five, their cartoons were an average of 2. The women gave themselves a 1. Even worse, 89 percent of the women and 94 percent of men responded that men, in general, are funnier. In a follow-up experiment, Mickes asked a new set of participants to read the captions generated by the first group and guess the gender of the writer.
Both men and women misattributed the funnier captions to male writers. To get some, mostly. Not everyone endorses evolutionary psychology, but those who do would say that women tend to be more selective in choosing their mates than men are because historically, motherhood has been a life-threatening, all-consuming endeavor.
If a cavewoman picked the wrong caveman, she might risk a grueling childbirth only to end up raising an illness-addled child without the help of a skillful mate. Thus, choosiness becomes paramount.
It behooves women to find a partner who will bestow sufficient time, resources, and good genes on their children—in other words, a smart man. Funny people are more likely to be smart. In one of the many New Yorker studies, the students who scored higher on intelligence tests also generated the funniest captions. On average, women tend to use their laughter to lure in potential mates, while men use their jokes to attract as many women as they can. For decades, this response stumped psychologists.
Women want men who will tell jokes; men want women who will laugh at theirs. Inpsychologists Eric Bressler and Sigal Balshine showed college students images of two equally attractive members of the opposite sex. Underneath each photo, they pasted either funny or not-funny statements supposedly authored by the person.
Female participants said they wanted the funny man, rather than the unfunny one, as a boyfriend, even when they thought the funnier man was less trustworthy. In study later that year, Bressler and Balshine again found that, when considering imaginary interactions with people of the opposite sex, women said they wanted men who could make them laugh. Men said it was much more important that a woman enjoy his jokes. Older studies of personal in magazines and newspapers found that women were far more likely than men to mention seeking someone funny.
Later, when researchers looked at profiles on a Canadian dating website, they found men were more likely to tout how funny they were, while women were likelier to say they wanted a funny man. Men ranked it third. If men try harder to be funny, women do their best to show their appreciation, laughing more enthusiastically and frequently in male company.
One study found that when men and women are talking, the amount that the woman, but not the man, laughs can predict whether the pair wants to date each other. My issue with him was that he took me out for dinner at a fancy place and only ordered chocolate milk.
I thought his issue was that there was another girl. It makes no sense. Norm violators get punished, and often, that means funny women are punished, too. In another dating-style study inabout college students were shown photos of people of the opposite sex along with transcripts of interviews supposedly conducted with those individuals. In the interviews, the photo subjects came off as either funny or bland. In a study out this month in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletinwhen men were introduced to women they were told had outperformed them on an intelligence test, they rated the woman as less attractive and were less likely to say they wanted to date her.
These biases have a chilling effect on women. A study that analyzed casual conversations among young people found that while men told more jokes and more successful jokes in mixed company, women told many more jokes when they were in all-female groups.
Sara Benincasa is certifiably funny. Which, given the scientific literature, made me worry that I will die alone. Benincasa said that when she was younger, in her teens and early 20s, she would soften her personality in order to please the men she was chasing romantically. Her friends would tell her that she acted differently around her boyfriends.
And the real me had a lot of things to say. She was not very funny.
Plight of the funny female
Her current boyfriend, she notes, is also funny, and he loves her for her wisecracking. If you can stimulate her to laughter … well, then, you have at least caused her to loosen up and to change her expression. Women can also stimulate people to laughter—not just for the purpose Hitchens had in mind, but to make a new friend, or to make an old one feel better. If funniness is an implement of power, women deserve access to it, too.
Buss is skeptical that human desire can be molded; that a stern PSA or even a shift in social mores could encourage men to seek out women who are witty rather than pretty. Hone, from the University of Missouri, is more optimistic.
The fascinating science behind your giggle fits. Popular Latest. The Atlantic Crossword. In Subscribe. Recommended Reading The Makeup Tax. There's No Such Thing as a Slut. The Evolution of Bitchiness.